Samaritan Snare
Wesley Crusher and Captain Picard travel together to Starbase 515 in a shuttlecraft. Wesley is going to take Starfleet exams. Captain Picard is going because he needs an operation on his heart. Doctor Pulaski offers to perform the operation aboard the Enterprise but Captain Picard would rather not have everyone aboard the ship learn of his cardiac condition.
The Enterprise gets a distress calls, while Wesley and the Captain are gone, from a Pakled ship. Geordi figures that he can get the Pakled ship up and running in no time at all. Commander Riker gives the go ahead so Geordi beams over and gets to work.
The Pakleds seem rather primitive but all is not as it seems. Once Geordi has fixed one thing aboard the Pakled ship they tell him that he can't leave they've got other things to fix. Once he is done fixing those things they still don't want to let him go.
Commander Riker, now fully aware that the Pakleds deceived him, turns to the senior officers for advice. They aren't much help so Riker comes up with a plan himself. He gives Geordi a coded message in front of the Pakleds. Geordi picks up on what Riker is saying and "fixes" the Pakled's weapon systems. Once it is clear to the Pakleds that they are defenseless they return Geordi to the Enterprise.
They Enterprise rushes to Starbase 515. Something has gone wrong with the operation on Captain Picard's heart. An expert is needed. That expert turns out to be Doctor Pulaski.
Thoughts
I enjoyed this episode very much, up to a point. I wasn't crazy about the way that the Pakled thread was resolved. I thought that Geordi would do something more dramatic which would cause their shields to drop so that the Enterprise could beam him back aboard. Something just didn't ring right to me about the way they intimidated the Pakled into changing their tune. It might have something to do with the fact that I've seen plenty of Pakled stories in the first two seasons of Lower Decks.
Similarly, I was a little disappointed with the resolution to the Picard surgery story thread. I didn't feel like anything was really gained by having Doctor Pulaski be the one to save Picard. It was a little too much of a reach in my opinion.
On the whole this isn't a bad episode but the final act didn't speak to me as much as the first four did.
Notes
Christopher Collins played Grebnediog, the Pakled Captain. This is the first of two episodes of this show in which he appeared. The other episode is 2.08 A Matter of Honor. He also appeared in two episodes of Deep Space Nine. This is the only episode in which he played a Pakled.
Lycia Naff made her second of two appearances in this show in this episode. She once again played the part of Ensign Sonya Gomez. Her previous appearance was in 2.16 Q Who. She came back to play Captain Sonya Gomez in an episode of Lower Decks, 2.10 First First Contact.
Robert McCullough, Hans Beimler, and Richard Manning are credited as the writers of this episode. This is the second of two episodes of this show that McCullough is credited with writing. This is one of 19 episodes of this show that Beimler and Manning are credited with writing. I've seen at least six of those 19 episodes, which include 2.19 Manhunt. Beimler and Manning also collaborated on one episode of Deep Space Nine. Beimler went on to write 25 more episodes of DS9 without Manning.
This is one of 22 episodes of this show that Les Landau directed. This is the earliest of those episodes that I have seen. One of the other episodes he directed was 6.15 Tapestry in which Picard re-experiences the bar fight, that he mentioned in this episode, in which his heart was badly damaged when he was a young Starfleet officer.
No comments:
Post a Comment